Forum Replies Created

Viewing 12 replies - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • in reply to: Time limit for unit entitlement reallocations? #29968
    Waratah
    Flatchatter
    Chat-starter

      Jimmy, you suggest that those who want redistribution who need to pay for a valuation, not all owners.

      The latest strata committee minutes show that the committee  has agreed to employ a valuer to assess the unit entitlements.

      At one point a price in the tens of thousands was suggested as the price to get a formal valuation.

      Does this need to go to a general meeting first?

      Waratah
      Flatchatter
      Chat-starter

        Thanks for the details about Stratabox. The website looks very slick and it seems like an excellent service for Owners Corporations.

        However, I think our Strata Manager might already have on-line facilities. I was mainly wondering what other Owners Corporations policies are regarding access to meeting papers.

        Waratah
        Flatchatter
        Chat-starter

          That’s definitely a good idea and I’ll give it a go.

          But I’m interested in knowing if there are other strata schemes that post papers on a website as a matter of course, without individual owners having to ask, and without it being dependant on the make-up of the current strata committee.

          I’ve seen mention of websites that some strata schemes use to communicate with owners and residents (though couldn’t name one without doing a search) and wonder whether some of them might use them to post business papers routinely.

          Waratah
          Flatchatter
          Chat-starter

            Our strata manager bundles all the various material to be considerred at the strata committee into one pdf for the committee members.

            I’ve seen a couple of them and the material sent out includes audits of the building, electricity agreement, discussion papers about unit entitlements, financial reports, papers regarding fire orders and cladding and drafts of various manuals that are being produced.

            Waratah
            Flatchatter
            Chat-starter

              Electronic voting sounds like it has some potential, but  has any Flat Chatter used it? How easy to use is it? Would people whose first language is not English, or the elderly, be able to use it easily?

              A quick scan of electronic voting brings up issues of security, technology failure (remember #censusfail?) and the loss of civic engagement as people don’t engage in a public forum, mindful of community responsibilities, but retreat to the privacy of their own home. Also, it could mean a pre meeting ‘meet the candidates’ would be needed so people could see nominees in action.

              Waratah
              Flatchatter
              Chat-starter

                There is a  small group of people who have been on the committee for a long time. With the end of proxy farming, new people got on the committee with a simple majority.  They brought in a new office manager. In the last elections the old guard called a poll vote and won by a small number of unit entitlements. There has been speculation that they may attempt to bring back the relative.

                I don’t have a clear view of how many people are afraid to vote but if there were enough, and we could remove their fear, it might be enough to swing the balance in our favour.

                in reply to: Odour problems in apartment building #29030
                Waratah
                Flatchatter

                  I’d be interested to hear what you arrive at Mary67 as we’re suffering the same thing in our apartment, except in our case it is particularly unpleasant smelling cigarette smoke.

                  The smell comes into all rooms of our unit. In fact, as I type now, I can smell it in our dining room, despite the Strata Manager sending an email to the resident yesterday (I’ll raise that issue in a more relevant topic) and I feel nauseous.

                  It’s totally unreasonable that residents should have to suffer this, it utterly affects our comfort and concentration on whatever it is we’re doing at the time.

                  in reply to: Does your sinking fund cost you money #28528
                  Waratah
                  Flatchatter

                    Thanks Jimmy, that is very helpful. I don’t have a feel for how many people in the building are for or against the idea of a strata loan right now.

                    One thing that has been suggested is that people who can’t afford the special levy in one hit without borrowing could organise their own loans/reverse mortgage, so not everyone needs to pay interest.

                    in reply to: Does your sinking fund cost you money #28525
                    Waratah
                    Flatchatter

                      When you say:

                      I personally think strata loans are a more equitable form of raising finance and they are probably less likely to scare the horses.

                      do you mean fairer than, say, a special levy?

                      Could you explain why you that is?

                      While it does spread payments out over a longer period of time, it does mean people end up paying more. in the case of our building it would be close to an extra million in interest. Unsurprisingly there’s quite a few people who would prefer to avoid that.

                      I suppose it’s like buying a house – few of us can pay for a house up front but can afford regular payments over a couple of decades. Maybe I’ve just answered my own question?

                      in reply to: Does your sinking fund cost you money #28520
                      Waratah
                      Flatchatter

                        Thanks Jimmy.

                        Just so I’m quite clear on this, does this paragraph below describe what some people might think if a loan is taken out?

                        However, if they are informed that major works are proposed and there will be X amount added to their levies for the next however long, that is not going to be a case of simple subtraction. Whether or not that puts them off buying is another matter entirely

                        in reply to: Does your sinking fund cost you money #28518
                        Waratah
                        Flatchatter

                          Our large strata scheme is facing building works of over $10 million and is currently debating how to fund them. There is discussion of a strata loan. “Just get on with it” said (on 20/9/2013):

                          The other issue is the heightened confusion and uncertainty added to prospective purchasers when they see strata loans disclosed as opposed to special levy payments.

                          Could someone explain why a strata loan causes more concern to a prospective purchaser than a large special levy?

                          Waratah
                          Flatchatter

                            I would say that, yes, buying and selling in NSW is broken.

                            We are currently in the process of purchasing a strata unit. My partner feels we have enough information, I have my doubts.

                            Old newspaper reports suggest this building has considerable building works required, possibly in the order of several million or more dollars.

                            We commissioned a Strata Report and it came back with a disclaimer that the records were poorly kept and therefore it could not be guaranteed that all records were provided.

                            I was advised that there are no Australian Standards setting out what should be in Strata Report.

                            When I requested a copy of a report recently prepared that EC minutes suggested would set out a comprehensive program of building works, the Owners Corporation declined to provide it and I was advised that they are not required to provide it.

                            How are people to make informed decisions about the most expensive purchase of their life? Even purchasing a Strata Report really doesn’t give you full information –  at the end of the day, it seems like information can be kept from prospective purchasers.

                            How are we supposed to caveat emptor (buyer beware) and make informed decisions about the full financial implications of purchasing a property in the absence of full disclosure of all relevant information?

                          Viewing 12 replies - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)