Flat Chat Strata Forum Common Property Current Page

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #71852
    Cake
    Flatchatter

      Hello Friends. The saga started nearly two years ago so I need to act promptly. There is a crack in the slab in the CP over our unit. Rain water penetrates into the unit below (our unit). I have my own report from a private builder to prove that the false ceiling is moist (70%).

      Builders hired by the OC identified the need to change the membrane and something else in the balcony above us. That unit is rented for over 1K a week.

      The OC now want to reduce the cost of fixing and send a plumber to do a dye test (which is useless) as the builders’ report is very clear – water penetrates into the unit below and no dye test is needed.

      Since the cost is 400-500K to repair the crack, the OC want to minimise the cost and fix only some of the membrane. If the plumber does the dye test, the coloured water would be flushed into our ceiling and would be  dripping for days through a hole that had been cut by a plumber last year .

      The overhead balcony is covered in mould. I want to apply to NCAT  and make OC raise the money to fix the membrane in the balcony above us (only our unit seems be getting water penetration) and appoint a manager to handle the matter. What orders should I choose in the application to NCAT?

      The strata is forcing us to do the dye test.

      The application has 1)general orders  2) managing agents 3) penalty for breach of by low

      Under which category will s106 fall?  or the appointment of a compulsory manager s 237?

      Could you please provide me with advice.

       

      • This topic was modified 11 months, 1 week ago by .
    Viewing 2 replies - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
    • Author
      Replies
    • #71904
      kaindub
      Flatchatter

        Appointment of a compulsory strata manager probably won’t work and is possibly an overkill

        The offer of the OC of a dye test by the plumber is a reasonable course of action. Remember that you hired the builder. The saying he who pays the piper calls the tune is applicable here. The OC just wants to get an independent verification of the cause.

        I’d do it as it will prove (if your builder is correct) the cause of the leak.

        Also if you go to NCAT(without the plumber report) , the OC is going to say but we are getting an independent test done so dont make an order yet

        Once they get the plumbers report insist they make a plan to fix the problem and if none is produced in 2 months then go to NCAT and seek orders to repair the common property

        $400-500k seems a lot of money to repair a membrane on a single balcony. I’d be assisting the OC by getting some other quotes (the new act says multiple quotes are required for work about $30k)

         

         

        #71930
        Cake
        Flatchatter
        Chat-starter

          Hi, thank you for your reply. The fact is it was their builders who did the water test just a few week ago. It showed water penetration straight away. I had to hire my builder just to prove that water does penetrate. The quotes are for demolition of the structures, waterproofing, placing new tiles, etc. The area is vast.<!–more–>

        Viewing 2 replies - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
        • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

        Flat Chat Strata Forum Common Property Current Page